Thursday, July 19, 2018

Building Cracks-Causes and Remedies


Cracks in concrete have several causes. They may show total extent of damage or problems of greater magnitude.
Added to that, they may represent critical structural distress, lack of durability, or they might influence appearance only. The importance of cracks dependent on the nature of cracking and type of structure.
Causes of different types of building cracks and their remedies will be discussed below.

The principal causes of cracks in a building are as follows:
  1. Permeability of concrete
  2. Thermal movement
  3. Creep movement
  4. Corrosion of reinforcement
  5. Moisture movement
  6. Poor construction practices
  7. Improper structural design and specifications
  8. Poor maintenance
  9. Movement due to chemical reactions
  10. other factors

1.Permeability of concrete

As deterioration process in concrete begins with penetration of various aggressive agents. it dictates the ability of concrete to withstand weathering action, chemical attack, or any process of deterioration. Therefore, low permeability is a key factor to concrete durability.
There are number of factors that controls concrete permeability like water-cement ratio, use of admixtures, curing, air voids due to deficient compaction, micro-cracks due to loading, cyclic exposure to thermal variations, and age of concrete.
The first three are allied to the concrete strength as well. The permeability of cement paste is a function of water-cement ratio given good quality materials, satisfactory proportioning and good construction practice; the permeability of the concrete is a direct function of the porosity and interconnection of pores of the cement paste.

Remedial measures

The above discussion suggests suitable measure to decrease concrete permeability and hence cracks.

2.Thermal movement

Thermal movement is one of the most potent causes of cracking in buildings. All materials more or less expand on heating and contract on cooling.
Ambient temperature changes and loss of heat of hydration in portion of structure at different rate lead to temperature variations and subsequent thermal movement.
The thermal movement in a component depends on a number of factors such as temperature variations, dimensions, coefficient of thermal expansion and some other physical properties of materials.
Thermal variations in the internal walls and intermediate floors are not much and thus do not cause cracking.
It is mainly the external walls especially thin walls exposed to direct solar radiation and the roof which are subject to substantial thermal variation that are liable to cracking.
Concrete cracking due to temperature variations
Fig.1: Concrete cracking due to temperature variations
Cracking due to thermal movement
Fig.2: Cracking due to thermal movement

Remedial Measures

Joints shall be considered during the design and constructed properly. For example, expansion joints, construction joints, control joints, and slip joints.
Joints to prevent cracking due to thermal movement
Fig.3: Joints to prevent cracking due to thermal movement

3.Creep Movement 

Gradual and slow time dependent deformation of concrete structure under sustained loads is known as creep.  It may generate excessive stress and lead to the crack development.
Creep increases with increase in water and cement content, water cement ratio and temperature.
Added to that, admixtures and pozzolans will increase creep. The increase of temperature in steel bars will increase creep as well.
However, it decreases with increase in humidity of surrounding atmosphere and age of material at the time of loading.
concrete building cracks due to creep movement
Fig.4:concrete building cracks due to creep movement
Remedial measures
  • Use minimum possible quantity of water.
  • Employ large course aggregate.
  • Provide compression reinforcement if possible
  • Avoid formwork removal at early ages.
  • Cure concrete properly.
  • assign proper cross section for the concrete element.

4.Corrosion of Reinforcement

Reinforcement corrosion will produce iron oxide and hydroxide on steel bar surface, consequently its volume increases.
This increase in volume causes high radial bursting stresses around reinforcing bars and result in local radial cracks. These splitting cracks results in the formation of longitudinal cracks parallel to the bar.
Reinforcement corrosion will occur unless it is protected properly. Steel reinforcement can be protected by providing adequate impervious concrete cover. This will prevent the ingression of moisture and other aggressive elements.
Steel corrosion will also not occur as long as concrete surrounding it is alkaline in nature having a high pH value.
Cracking due to corrosion of reinforcement
Fig.5: Cracking due to corrosion of reinforcement
Concrete cracking due corrosion of reinforcement
Fig.6:Concrete cracking due corrosion of reinforcement

Remedial Measures

  • Use low permeable concrete
  • Provide adequate cover thickness
  • Make sure concrete-steel bond is as good as possible. This is because concrete alone is not capable of resisting tensile forces to which it is often subjected. Otherwise, concrete may crack and allow harmful substance materials to attack steel bars.

5.Moisture Movement

Most of the building materials with pores in their structure in the form of inter-molecular space expand on absorbing moisture and shrink on drying.
These movements are cyclic in nature and are caused by increase or decrease in inter pore pressure with moisture changes.
Shrinkage can be of plastic or dry. Factors that cause cement or mortar to experience shrinkage include excessive water, and cement quantity; rich cement mixtures suffer greater shrinkage.
Crack above window due shrinkage
Fig.7:Crack above window due shrinkage
concrete cracking due to moisture movement
Fig.8:concrete cracking due to moisture movement

Remedial measures

  • Provide movement joints
  • Use minimum possible quantity of water for mixing cement concrete or cement mortar
  • Compact concrete properly; vibrated concrete suffers lesser shrinkage compare with manually compacted concrete
  • Finally, avoid the use of excessive cement.

6.Poor Construction practices

There are broad variety of construction practices that lead to concrete cracking. Normally, improper construction practices are due to ignorance, carelessness, greed or negligence.
main causes for poor construction practices:
  • Improper selection of materials.
  • Selection of poor quality cheap materials.
  • Inadequate and improper proportioning of mix constituents of concrete, mortar etc.
  • Inadequate control on various steps of concrete production such as batching, mixing, transporting, placing, finishing and curing
  • Construction overloads induced during construction can frequently be more serious than those imposed during service.
  • Inadequate quality control and supervision causing large voids (honey combs) and cracks resulting in leakages and ultimately causing faster deterioration of concrete.
  • Improper construction joints between subsequent concrete pours or between concrete framework and masonry.
  • Addition of excess water in concrete and mortar mixes.
  • Lastly, poor quality of plumbing and sanitation materials and practices.
Concrete building cracking due to poor construction practice
Fig.9:Concrete building cracking due to poor construction practice; water added to fresh concrete

Remedial measure

  • monitoring construction process properly.
  • Utilize good quality materials at the time of construction.

7.Improper structural design and specifications

Several problems can occur due to incorrect structural design, detailing, and specifications.
Errors that may occur at this stage include inadequate thickness, insufficient reinforcement, incorrect geometry, improper utilization of materials, and incorrect detailing.
Problems encountered due to those errors include cracking due to insufficient reinforcement, excessive differential movement due to improper foundation design, increased concentration of stresses as a result of poorly design re-entrant etc.…
Additionally, it is of crucial that the designer consider the environmental conditions existing around the building site.
Major structural crack in beam due to poor detailing practice
Fig.10:Major structural crack in beam due to poor detailing practice

Remedial measures

Architects, Structural Consultants and Specifiers shall consider the following measure to avoid cracking and subsequent deterioration of structures:
  • Proper specification for concrete materials and concrete.
  • Proper specifications to take care of environmental as well as sub – soil conditions.
  • Constructible and adequate structural design.
  • Proper quality and thickness of concrete cover around the reinforcement steel.
  • Planning proper reinforcement layout and detailing the same in slender structures to facilitate proper placing of concrete without segregation.
  • Selection of proper agency to construct their designs.

8.Poor Maintenance

A structure needs to be maintained after a lapse of certain period from its construction completion.
Some structures may need a very early look into their deterioration problems, while others can sustain themselves very well for many years depending on the quality of design and construction.
Moreover, regular external painting of the building to some extent helps in protecting the building against moisture and other chemical attacks.
Water-proofing and protective coating on reinforcement steel or concrete are all second line of defense and the success of their protection will greatly depend on the quality of concrete.
Leakages should be attended to at the earliest possible before corrosion of steel inside concrete starts and spalling of concrete takes place.
Furthermore, Spalled concrete will lose its strength and stiffness. besides, The rate of corrosion increases because the rusted steel is entirely exposed to aggressive environment.
Finally, it is not only essential to repair the deteriorated concrete but it is equally important to prevent the moisture and aggressive chemicals to enter concrete and prevent further deterioration.
Leakage from roof slab
Fig.11:Leakage from roof slab

9.Movement due to Chemical reactions

The concrete may crack as a result of expansive reactions between aggregate, which contains active silica, and alkaline derived from cement hydration.
The alkali silica reaction results in the formation of swelling gel. This tends to draw water from other portions of concrete. Consequently, local expansion occur and results in cracks in the structure.
Cracking due to alkali silica reactions
Fig.12:Cracking due to alkali-silica reactions

Remedial measures

  • Use low alkali cement
  • Employ pozzolana
  • Select proper aggregates.

10.Others factors

  • Brutal decoration, free to remove the load-bearing walls or holes, causing cracks.
  • Fires caused by accidents, fires, mild earthquakes, etc.

Wednesday, July 18, 2018

Economical Design of Reinforced Concrete Columns to Reduce Cost


Economical design of reinforced concrete columns and its construction practices and recommendations to reduce its cost of construction is discussed. Columns are the major elements in reinforced concrete structures and the safety and stability of the structure greatly depends on it.
The cost of a column per linear meter per MPa of load carrying capacity substantially varies due to several factors, for example, the location of the column in the structure (exterior column and interior column) and the configuration of the loads imposed on the column and others.
However, there are number of recommendations and measure by which a cost effective reinforced concrete column can be designed and constructed. These recommendations will be discussed in the following sections.
Reinforced Concrete Column Construction
Fig.1: Reinforced Concrete Column Construction

Recommendations for Economical Design of Reinforced Concrete Columns

Recommendation provided for economical design of reinforced concrete columns are as follow:
  • Strength of concrete employed for reinforced concrete column
  • Formwork used for casting reinforced concrete column
  • Steel reinforcements used in the reinforced concrete column construction
  • Details of reinforcement of concrete column

Strength of Concrete for Reinforced Concrete Column

A valuable recommendation provided regarding concrete strength is the use of maximum concrete compressive strength needed to carry factored loads and lowest permissible reinforcement ratio. This is because the lowest price would be reached if such measure is practiced as the cost of reinforcement reduces.
It is claimed that, the use of minimum reinforcement ratio for a given column would reduce total column cost significantly (around 32% for concrete strength of 56MPa and 57% for concrete strength of 100MPa) compared with the case where maximum reinforcement ratio is utilized.
The smallest size of columns in multi storey structures is specified based on the maximum concrete compressive strength and a limit on the maximum reinforcement ratio.
If the size of column is smaller than the minimum allowable size at the base of the structure, then reinforcement ratio can be decreased.
Finally, both reinforcement ratio and concrete compressive strength can be decreased as the imposed factored loads decline in the upper storeys.
Economical Design of Reinforced Concrete Columns
Fig.2: Dimension and Reinforcements of Columns

Formwork Used for Casting Reinforced Concrete Column

It is recommended to use the same size and shape for reinforced concrete column for the all floors and from footing to the roof.
Not only does this strategy would allow to construction large number of columns (mass production) but also the formwork of columns can be reused again.
One may argue that, using the same size for all columns would lead to utilize large quantity of additional concrete and hence it would be uneconomical.
However, it is proven that, savings achieved from formwork cost and fast construction would be much greater than the cost of extra material used for smaller columns of storeys above. Added to that, this strategy is claimed to be applicable for maximum building height of 188.2m
column-formwork
Fig.3: Column Formwork
Formwork Used for Casting Reinforced Concrete Column
Fig.4: The Same Size and Shape of Column used in the Construction of Multi Storey Building

Steel Reinforcements used in the Reinforced Concrete Column Construction

It is advised to conduct cost comparison between various combination of concrete compressive strength and steel yield strength to specify combination that provides lowest cost.
It is reported that, the use of high strength concrete with 520MPa yield strength would need lowest cost.
Another measure to decrease cost of reinforcements is to utilize minimum tie bars without the violation of code specifications.
Minimum tie requirement would be reached if a longitudinal steel bar is installed at each corner of the column.
If minimum tie requirement is realized, then it would not be necessary to use interior ties.
Consequently, not only can low slump concrete be poured and properly compacted but also the time and cost required to install column reinforcement would be reduced.

Detailing of Reinforcement of Concrete Column

It is possible to make savings in splices subjected to compression only (in another word, end bearing mechanical splices). Added to that, it is advised to employ staggering in order to make the mechanical end bearing to resist certain amount of bending.
Compression Only Mechanical Splices
Fig.5: Compression Only Mechanical Splices
Commonly, tensile splice of steel bar with 32mm size is required to be employed if the column subjected to large bending force. In this case, it is recommended to use mechanical splice because it is more economical.
However, if the size of the bar is smaller than 32mm, then it is more economical to consider lap splice rather than mechanical splice.
Detailing of Reinforcement of Concrete Column
Fig.6: Lap Splice in Column

What is Foundation Settlement? Its Types and Causes


What is foundation settlement?

Inevitably, soils deform under the load of foundation structures. The total vertical displacement that occur at foundation level is termed as settlement. The cause of foundation settlement is the reduction of volume air void ratio in the soil.
Moreover, the magnitude of foundation settlement is controlled by many factors type of soil and foundation structure. Foundations on bedrock settle a negligible amount. In contrary, Foundations in other types of soil such as clay may settle much more.
An example of this is Mexico City palace of fine arts has settled more than 15 feet (4.5m) into the clay soil on which it is founded since it was constructed in the early 1930s.
However, building foundation settlement is normally limited to amounts measured in millimeter or fractions of an inch.
Structures will suffer damages due to settlement of its foundation specifically when the settlement occur in quick manner.
In this article, different types of foundation settlement along with their cases and expected effects on the structure will be discussed.

Types of foundation settlement

  • Differential foundation settlement
  • Uniform foundation settlement

Differential foundation settlement

  • Settlement that occurs at differing rates between different portions of a building is termed differential settlement.
  • Differential settlement occurs if there is difference in soils, loads, or structural systems between parts of a building. in this case, different parts of the building structure could settle by substantially different amounts.
  • Consequently, the frame of the building may become distorted, floors may slope, walls and glass may crack, and doors and windows may not work properly.
  • Uneven foundation settlement may force buildings to shift out of plumb which lead to crack initiation in foundation, structure, or finish.
  • Majority of foundation failures are attributable to severe differential settlement.
  • Lastly, for conventional buildings with isolated foundations, 20mm differential settlement is acceptable. And 50mm total settlement is tolerable for the same structures.
differential settlement
Fig.1:Differential settlement
Cracks due to differential settlement
Fig.2:Cracks due to differential settlement

Uniform foundation settlement

  • when foundation settlement occurs at nealy the same rate throughout all portions of a building, it is called uniform settlement.
  • If all parts of a building rest on the same kind of soil, then uniform settlement the most probable type to take place.
  • Similarly, when loads on the building and the design of its structural system are uniform throughout, the anticipated settlement would be uniform type.
  • Commonly, uniform settlement has small detrimental influence on the building safety.
  • However, it influences utility of the building for example damaging sewer; water supply; and mains and jamming doors and windows.
Fig.3:Uniform foundation settlement, no cracks development
Settlement of foundation
Fig.4: Difference between uniform and differential settlement

Foundation settlement causes

Direct causes

  • The direct cause of foundation settlement is the weight of building including dead load and live load.

Indirect causes

  • Failure of collapsible soil underground infiltration
  • Yielding of excavation done adjacent to foundation
  • Failure of underground tunnels and mines
  • Collapse of cavities of limestones
  • Undermining of foundation while flood
  • Earthquake induced settlement
  • Finally, due to extraction of ground water and oil.

Components of total settlement of foundations

Immediate settlement

  • It is also called short term settlement.
  • Immediate settlement take place mostly in coarse grained soils of high permeability and in unsaturated fine-grained soils of low permeability.
  • Lastly, it occurs over short period of time which about 7 days. So, it ends during construction time.

Primary settlement

  • It also termed as primary consolidation
  • Take place over long period of time that ranges from 1 to 5 years or more
  • Primary settlement frequently occurs in saturated inorganic fine grain soil.
  • Expulsion of water from pores of saturated fine grain soil is the cause of primary settlement.

Secondary settlement

  • Secondary settlement is the consolidation of soil under constant effective stress.
  • Frequently, it occurs in organic fine grain soil.
  • It continues over the life span of foundation structure similar to creep in concrete.